Ministry of Electronics & IT
“Stealing and Mining of App Data can lead even to unanticipated National Security Risks”
Posted On: 04 JUL 2020 9:48AM
Mumbai, July 4, 2020
The Government of India, on 29th June, 2020, made an necessary announcement. The Ministry of Electronics & Information Technology banned 59 cell apps, primarily based on info that these apps threaten the sovereignty and integrity of India, defence of India, safety of state and public order. The record of apps which can not be obtainable to customers in India consists of the favored social media platform TikTook, file switch service ShareIt, social networking service Helo and doc scanning software CamScanner. The Government has finished this by invoking its powers beneath Section 69A of the Information Technology Act, in addition to related provisions of the Information Technology (Procedure and Safeguards for Blocking of Access of Information by Public) Rules 2009.
Stealing and Mining of Data by Elements Hostile to National Security
One of the explanations that led to the ban of those apps is the intelligence that some apps have been stealing and surreptitiously transmitting customers’ knowledge to servers primarily based exterior India. Well, this would possibly make somebody marvel: how can transmission of seemingly innocuous knowledge from one thing like a social networking app threaten the nationwide safety and defence of the nation?
To achieve a greater appreciation of the gravity of the problem which can are usually seemed upon as a comparatively innocent challenge by the lay individual, allow us to hear from Dr. Deepak P., Assistant Professor of Computer Science at Queen’s University Belfast (United Kingdom) who makes a speciality of Artificial Intelligence and Data Ethics. Dr. Deepak explains the sensitivities concerned in using purposes run by companies that are primarily based exterior India and who’re certain by the legal guidelines and laws prevailing in another country. The knowledge collected by these companies could also be saved on servers positioned exterior the nation. While such knowledge usually resides within the custody of the corporate itself, they could should honour knowledge requests obtained by governments of these international locations. Moreover, many companies have been discovered to honour such requests, which thereby poses the danger of Indian customers’ knowledge entering into powers which may use that info strategically, towards our nationwide pursuits.
Data is highly effective. Data Mining applied sciences have change into very superior as we speak, throwing open some ways wherein hazard might strike. Dr. Deepak cites the instance of on-line health tracker app Strava, a San Francisco primarily based service that makes use of a cell phone’s GPS to trace the subscriber’s train exercise. It allows customers to judge and evaluate their efficiency with one another and over time. In November 2017, the app launched a heatmap – an information visualization of 27 billion kilometres of working exercise recorded on the app between 2015 and September 2017, containing round 3 trillion knowledge factors. Looking on the knowledge, Nathan Ruser, a younger worldwide safety scholar at an Australian college realized this may be harmful. Why? It occurred to him that among the many tens of millions of customers of the app are army personnel who commonly go for working and jogging. He discovered that the app knowledge can reveal unknown details about army bases, together with the routes taken by troopers, generally used train routes and patrolled roads. This may therefore pose a direct menace to nationwide safety.
Another level to keep in mind when considering of information and knowledge safety, says Dr. Deepak, is that we is not going to usually be capable to anticipate the myriad methods wherein an information set can find yourself getting used, whereas the information is being produced and even transmitted. The above instance of the working app illustrates this. He gave one other instance, of what’s referred to as forensic family tree, whereby genetic info sourced from shopper firms are used to determine suspects or victims in felony circumstances. This has been utilized by police in USA to unravel many circumstances, remembers Dr. Deepak. The DNA profile from the crime scene is uploaded to a public-access database containing genetic info of individuals. The database allows identification of relations primarily based on comparability of DNA profiles, thereby serving to legislation enforcement companies in figuring out potential suspects or victims of circumstances.
The Government of India has stated that the compilation of information from cell apps and its mining and profiling by parts hostile to nationwide safety and defence of India is a matter of very deep and quick concern which requires emergency measures.
Need for More Public Awareness
Dr. Deepak says there’s a want for constructing and selling better public consciousness on knowledge privateness and knowledge and knowledge safety. There has been an exceptional enlargement in our use of digital applied sciences. While they enhance our lives in some ways, it’s essential to be aware and conscious additionally of the dangers they pose and to be considered customers of cell and web applied sciences. On this explicit determination of banning the 59 cell apps, Dr. Deepak says that it is going to be useful for the federal government to let residents know the particular methods wherein these apps pose a menace and the main points of the method by which the complaints and studies which led to the ban had been obtained and examined, to instill public confidence that due course of has been adopted and required motion taken in time. He provides that doing so will even assist enhance public understanding and participation on this challenge, in a deliberative democracy comparable to ours.
Does the Ban Violate WTO Regime?
The Government of India has invoked the ban to safeguard the pursuits of crores of Indian cell and web customers and to make sure the security and sovereignty of Indian our on-line world. However, the Chinese embassy in New Delhi, has expressed concern relating to the choice, stating, amongst different issues, that the choice “suspects of violating the WTO rules”. Let us hearken to Dr. James J. Nedumpara, Professor and Head, Centre for Trade and Investment Law, Indian Institute of Foreign Trade to assist us consider the validity of this argument.
Dr. Nedumpara says that it might be troublesome to ascertain a National Treatment obligation (i.e., obligation to deal with foreigners and locals equally) from India, by way of its providers commitments by way of the apps. The apps don’t particularly come beneath the schedule of concessions of WTO’s General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS). In his view, the argument that India has violated Most Favoured Nation obligation can also be not tenable. In any case, he notes that no matter any commerce obligations, India’s measures squarely fall throughout the nationwide safety exceptions supplied beneath Article XIV bis of GATS. Dr. Nedumpara explains that there was a transparent case of emergency in worldwide relations which has been prevalent on the time the choice has been taken. Further, India has already articulated its safety pursuits in taking the choice. He provides that whereas the official statements by the 2 international locations don’t expressly point out any connection between the border stress and the choice to ban the apps, a sufficiently sturdy case may be constructed primarily based on the accompanying incidents. Dr. Nedumpara makes it clear that India is therefore able to show the existence of all necessities needed for the invocation of the nationwide safety exception beneath GATS. He nonetheless added that recourse to commerce exceptions shouldn’t be known as for within the absence of any commerce violations.
***
Dheep Joy Mampilly
(The writer is an officer of the Indian Information Service, primarily based at present in Mumbai; e-mail – [email protected])
(Features ID: 150654)
0
